home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- THEATER, Page 76Razor's Edge
-
-
- Imagining Sweeney's world
-
-
- The first time around, Sweeney Todd, the gruesome tale of
- a deranged barber who slits customers' throats and a pragmatic
- landlady who bakes the victims into meat pies, was a Victorian
- penny dreadful by way of Brecht. Everything imitated him: Hugh
- Wheeler's book, Stephen Sondheim's score, Harold Prince's
- staging and even the set, which resembled an iron foundry; it
- hissed and clanged of the dehumanization of the Industrial
- Revolution. Audiences in 1979 flinched at the spewing blood and
- spoken bile: it seemed there had never been so cynical a
- musical.
-
- A kinder, gentler Sweeney was unimaginable until Susan H.
- Schulman's intimate reconsideration arrived on Broadway last
- week. This time the tale comes by way of Dickens. London's
- gaslit windows ring the circular seating. Tattered gray laundry
- sags from clotheslines all around. Turbulent street life spills
- into the aisles. Gloomy, angry and unjust Sweeney's world
- remains, but human connections now matter.
-
- Sweeney and his landlady are at bottom leftist
- abstractions. He is the innocent man turned criminal by a wicked
- power structure; exiled by a corrupt judge who lusted after his
- wife, he returns vowing to show nobody any more mercy than he
- received. Mrs. Lovett is a singing, dancing and grimacing Mother
- Courage, sapped of moral scruple by economic privation and sheer
- will to survive. Beth Fowler and Bob Gunton sing nobly, and the
- production's intimacy includes a welcome emphasis on natural,
- unmiked sound. She enriches Lovett with a lifelong ardor for
- Sweeney and a pixilated fondness for romantic fancy. He
- believably underscores the improvisatory quality of Sweeney's
- first murders, turning him from a monster into a man who howls
- piteously over the body of his beloved wife, lost and too late
- found. As corpses pile up in the apocalyptic finale, this
- version urges spectators not only to think but also to feel.
-
-